Fresh from our kitchen

Our menu

Everything is made from scratch, baked to order, and packed with love. Browse our offerings and place a custom order request below.

Tell us your cupcake flavor and choice of buttercream frosting flavor (some frosting ideas: coffee, mint, lemon, maple, apple, orange, Oreo, peanut butter, coconut, blueberry, cherry & more) 
Classic Vanilla

Classic Vanilla

From $4.00

Light vanilla cake topped with silky vanilla buttercream and a sprinkle of rainbow nonpareils.

Order this
Double Chocolate
Fan favorite

Double Chocolate

From $4.00

Rich chocolate cake with whipped chocolate ganache frosting. For the serious chocolate lover.

Order this
Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter

From $4.00

Moist chocolate cake swirled high with a rich peanut butter buttercream frosting.

Order this
Strawberry Dream
Seasonal

Strawberry Dream

From $4.00

Fresh strawberry cake with strawberry cream cheese frosting and a dried strawberry garnish.

Order this
Custom Flavors
Seasonal

Custom Flavors

From $4.00

Tell us your cupcake flavor and choice of buttercream frosting flavor.

Order this
Red Velvet

Red Velvet

From $4.00

Classic red velvet with a hint of cocoa, topped with tangy cream cheese frosting.

Order this
Custom Celebration Cake
Custom

Custom Celebration Cake

From $75

Fully custom layered cakes for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, and any occasion. Choose your flavors, fillings, and design.

Order this
Drip Cake
Popular

Drip Cake

From $90

Showstopping ganache drip cake with smooth buttercream and elegant finishing touches.

Order this
Cupcake Bouquet

Cupcake Bouquet

From $35

Say it with a beautiful (and edible!) cupcake flower bouquet to brighten someone’s special day.

Order this
Cakesicles

Cakesicles

$30 / half dozen

Moist popsicle-shaped cake pops dipped in chocolate and expertly embellished. Sold by the half dozen.

Order this
Rice Krispie Treats

Rice Krispie Treats

$36 / dozen

Gooey, buttery Rice Krispie treats dipped in chocolate and decorated for any occasion. Sold by the dozen.

Order this
Mini Loaf Cakes
Custom

Mini Loaf Cakes

$36 / half dozen

Each cake is 6.8 ounces of rich cake and sweet buttercream frosting in your choice of flavors. Sold by the half dozen.

Order this
Special / Bulk Order
Inquire

Special / Bulk Order

Custom pricing

Planning a wedding, corporate event, or large party? We love big orders! Reach out for custom pricing and availability.

Order this

Place an order

Ready to order? Fill out the form and we'll get back to you within 24 hours to confirm availability and details. Payment is collected upon confirmation. Five days notice is required for all orders.

Cupcake varieties *

Minimum 2 per variety · Minimum 6 total

6 cupcakes total
Variety 1
Frosted

Handmade with love from our cottage kitchen in North Haven, CT. Every bite is baked to make your day a little sweeter.

Proudly serving North Haven & greater CT

Stay Connected

North Haven, CT

(203) 668-6856

[email protected]

Mon–Sat 9am–5pm  ·  Sun 12–4pm

© 2026 Frosted. All rights reserved.

Made with in North Haven, CT